CD Baby vs. DistroKid: Which is Better?

As an independent artist, choosing the right music distribution platform is crucial to getting your music heard by a broader audience. Two of the most popular names in the industry are CD Baby and DistroKid. This article will provide a detailed comparison between both platforms, focusing on their features, costs, and payout structures to help you decide which is the better choice for your music career.

Overview of CD Baby and DistroKid

CD Baby and DistroKid are two well-respected music distribution services that help artists distribute their music to digital streaming platforms such as Spotify, Apple Music, and Amazon Music.

CD Baby was founded in 1998 and offers a range of services, including physical distribution, digital distribution, and even DIY musician tools like artist websites and social media promotions. It is well known for providing comprehensive support and various marketing options to indie artists.

DistroKid, on the other hand, is a newer service that launched in 2013. It quickly gained popularity by offering unlimited music uploads for a flat annual fee. Unlike other platforms, DistroKid focuses on simplicity and efficiency, making music distribution fast and affordable for artists.

Features Comparison

CD Baby Features

• Digital and physical distribution
• Sync licensing
• Mastered for iTunes
• Publishing administration
• Music store & download cards
• Song registration with worldwide collection agencies

DistroKid Features

• Unlimited song uploads
• Automatic revenue splits
• Instantly verified Spotify profiles
• Official YouTube Channel (for subscribers)
• Store maximizer
• Cover song licensing

Cost Comparison

CD Baby Cost

CD Baby charges a one-time fee per release. For a single, the distribution fee is $9.95, and for an album, the cost is $29.95. CD Baby also takes a 9% commission on digital sales, which covers, among other things, the collection and payment of royalties.

DistroKid Cost

DistroKid offers a subscription-based model. For $19.99 per year, you can upload unlimited songs and albums. There are additional subscription tiers available that include more advanced features, such as customizable release dates and pre-order options.

Payout Structure

CD Baby Payout

CD Baby collects sales revenue from digital and physical sales, then distributes the earnings to artists after taking a 9% commission on digital sales. Payments are distributed monthly through PayPal, direct deposit, or check. CD Baby also ensures that artists receive royalties from various sources, including digital platforms, sync licensing, and publishing.

DistroKid Payout

DistroKid boasts one of the fastest payout structures in the industry. Artists keep 100% of their royalties, and revenues are distributed as soon as they are received by the platform. Payments are made through PayPal, direct deposit, or check. DistroKid offers a "bank" feature where artists can track their earnings in real-time.

User Experience

CD Baby

CD Baby offers a comprehensive platform that's well-suited for artists looking for a range of services and hands-on support. The platform might seem more intricate for those who are solely focused on digital distribution, but for artists wanting a one-stop shop, CD Baby provides valuable tools and services.

DistroKid

DistroKid's user experience is built around simplicity and speed. Its interface is highly intuitive, and it’s easy to upload and distribute music quickly. For artists who release music frequently and need a straightforward platform without added frills, DistroKid is an excellent choice.

Which Platform Should You Choose?

Choosing between CD Baby and DistroKid ultimately depends on your specific needs as an artist. If you're seeking a fully-featured platform with a range of extra services, CD Baby might be the better choice despite its per-release fee. However, for those who prioritize unlimited uploads and a straightforward approach, DistroKid offers excellent value for money with its flat annual rate.

If you're looking for an all-in-one platform that offers seamless marketing and distribution, consider SoundOn. This platform helps artists build careers and find new fans through TikTok and other digital streaming platforms.

In conclusion, both CD Baby and DistroKid have their merits, offering unique advantages to independent artists. Evaluate your priorities, such as cost, features, and ease of use, to make the best decision for your music career.